Italian Food in Southeast Annadale, Staten Island

Seafood pasta and cheese-topped pizza highlight Italian food at ‘O Sfizio Ristorante in Southeast Annadale, Staten Island, with pickup.

Order online

Italian Appetizers

Calamari

$19.00

Squid is served pan-fried oreganata or sweet-and-sour agrodolce.

“Osfizio is a gem. The food was outstanding and the service took it to another level. Mario took care of us and honestly made the day. Super professional, great energy, and on top of every detail without being overbearing... Heard he’s the owner’s son! Makes sense, he’s running the floor like he owns it already. Big boss in the making. Can’t recommend this place enough. Get the sweet and sour calamari 😋And the salmon was out of this world!”

Antipasto Italiano

$37.00

Cured Italian meats and cheeses come with olives, fig jam, and crostini.

Gamberi Oreganata

$22.00

Five shrimp baked with seasoned breadcrumbs for a crisp-topped appetizer.

Mozzarella In Carrozza

$18.00

Fried mozzarella layered with bread comes with tomato sauce.

Salads

Insalata La Pera

$18.00

Greens with pears, candied walnuts, Gorgonzola, and fig balsamic.

“Most amazing food and service. Went there for lunch at 11:30 on Sunday. The minute the door opened the owner was super friendly asking us, "Where have you been" lol. Hilarious. We ordered a pear salad, tortellini in brodo and a personal vodka pizza. All A+ amazing! Pizza is fluffy fresh and delicious. If you haven't been there! Get there!”

Insalata Arugula

$17.00

Arugula salad with nuts, goat cheese, red onion, and white wine vinaigrette.

“This is an excellent Italian restaurant — truly one of the best in New York. The food and service are absolutely top-tier, everything was perfect from start to finish. The atmosphere is magical, very cozy, elegant, and welcoming. You can really feel the attention to detail in everything they do. Every dish was delicious and beautifully presented, and the staff made the whole experience even more special. It’s definitely a place you want to come back to again. Highly recommend!”

Insalata Finocchio e Arancio

$18.00

Fennel, orange, and baby arugula salad with red wine vinegar.

“IF We could give this Fabulous Italian restaurant 10 stars …we would. Thank You Gennaro for such great service. FOOD was the BEST we have ever tasted!!”

Insalate Tre Colore

$18.00

Arugula, endive, radicchio, tomato, Parmesan, and balsamic dressing.

Soups

Escarole & Bean Soup (Lunch)

$9.00

Escarole and bean soup, listed on the lunch menu.

“We had a wonderful experience at this Italian restaurant! The staff was incredibly friendly, the food was absolutely delicious, and they went out of their way to make us feel welcome. They even helped keep our 1-year-old entertained so we could enjoy our meal—such a thoughtful touch. Highly recommend!”

Zuppe Escarole e Fagioli

$14.00

Soup combining leafy escarole with beans for a simple, savory bowl.

Pasta Fagioli (Lunch)

$9.00

Italian pasta and bean soup served as a lunch dish.

Zuppe Pasta e Fagioli

$14.00

Pasta and beans come together in this Italian-style soup.

Pasta

Linguine Vongole

$29.00

Linguine with garlic-sautéed clams and a choice of red or white sauce.

“Cannot say enough took daughter there for birthday everything was top notch food was delicious did not have to ask for a thing server was there with anything that the table needed. We were waited on like Kings and Queens. Can't even begin to describe how delicious the food was. Not your typical Staten Island Italian. Went on a whim will go again and again very impressed!”

Fioretti Boscaiola

$29.00

Four-cheese pasta purses with mushrooms, pancetta, cream, and truffle oil.

“What a lovely and beautiful neighborhood restaurant. The service was on point, and we will definitely be returning for the food. We recommend the grilled octopus, pollo Sophia Loren, and the money bags pasta.”

Truffle Rigatoni

$28.00

Rigatoni in truffle sauce with crumbled sausage and mushrooms.

“This place is absolutely the best Italian restaurant I have been. The food is outstanding without fail. Me and the wife had the arrabiata and it was to die for. The ribeye steak was sooo good too. The service is amazing and very friendly. Worth every penny.”

Spaghetti Carbonara

$29.00

Spaghetti with pancetta, onions, Grana Padano, and egg yolk.

Pizza

Vodka Pizza

$18.00

Pizza topped with mozzarella, vodka sauce, and Grana Padano.

“My favorite spot on Staten Island. Everything is incredible from the service to the food. The Vodka pizza is OUTSTANDING- I dream about it. Have never had a bad experience here in all the years we have been coming. Couldn’t recommend it more.”

Margherita Pizza

$17.00

Pizza with tomato sauce, mozzarella, Grana Padano, basil, and olive oil.

“Such a great spot! The food tastes homemade — the pasta was fresh, the pizza had the perfect thin crust, and everything was super flavorful. The staff was so welcoming and made us feel right at home. Good portions, fair prices, and just an all-around cozy vibe. Can’t wait to go back!”

Capricciosa Pizza

$19.00

Mozzarella, ham, mushrooms, artichokes, and olives top tomato-sauce pizza.

Spicy Honey Pizza

$18.00

Pepperoni, mozzarella, and hot honey top this spicy tomato-sauce pizza.

Seafood

Risotto Pescatore

$35.00

Seafood risotto with mussels, clams, shrimp, and calamari in tomato sauce.

“Amazing food and amazing service, highly recommend visiting. We had calamari, personal pizza’s, baked claims, risotto, everything was great!”

Tre Di Mare

$39.00

Branzino, bay scallops, and shrimp in lemon-wine sauce over spinach.

Filet of Sole Oreganata

$37.00

Sole fillet baked with seasoned crumbs, wine-lemon sauce, and vegetables.

Gamberi Scampi

$34.00

Sautéed shrimp in lemon and white wine sauce over linguine.

Chicken

Pollo Prosecco

$29.00

Chicken in prosecco sauce with artichoke, sun-dried tomato, and cream.

“Stopped in after attending a wake in the area. Ordered the chicken capricciosa with a nice spread of antipasto before the meal. Everything was absolutely fresh. Chicken cooked to perfection. My buddy got the sole almondine. Gennaro was great. Guys got a personality of gold. I would absolutely stop in again. If you are looking for great Italian cuisine & hospitality this is your spot.”

Pollo Sophia Loren

$33.00

Pan-seared chicken with prosciutto and olives in sherry sauce.

Pollo Any Style

$29.00

Chicken with a choice of four styles, served with vegetables and potatoes.

Pollo Capricciosa

$28.00

Pan-fried chicken with arugula, mozzarella, tomato, and balsamic glaze.

Desserts

Tiramisu

$12.00

Espresso-soaked ladyfingers layered with mascarpone cheese.

Fresh Napoleon

$17.00

Layered pastry filled with vanilla custard and served with fruit.

“Food was delicious, staff is very attentive, try the Napoleon, outstanding”

Italian Cheesecake

$14.00

Ricotta cheesecake with orange zest and raspberry drizzle.

“I've been living in New York for 3 years. And for the first time I visited A REALLY ITALIAN RESTAURANT. It's a great place, with delicious food and good wine!!! I recommend everyone to visit this place!”

Tartufo

$14.00

Vanilla-chocolate ice cream has almond, cherry, and a hard chocolate shell.

“I LOVE IT SO MUCHHH AMAZING ICE CREAM 🤤🤤🤤 The food was so great and everyone was so nice and funny❤️ I would come again any time”

Made with Care at ‘O Sfizio Ristorante

At ‘O Sfizio Ristorante, Italian food spans seafood risotto in light tomato sauce, pizza with sausage and broccoli rabe, and salads with poached pears, candied walnuts and Gorgonzola cheese.

Spicy Rigatoni comes in spicy vodka sauce, while Rigatoni Bolognese features slow-simmered ground beef ragù. Lobster Ravioli is filled with lobster and served in a creamy pink champagne sauce.

Visit us in Southeast Annadale, Staten Island for pickup, dine-in or delivery. For a sweet finish, Fresh Napoleon has millefoglie layered with rich vanilla custard and is served with fruit.

Frequently Asked Questions

What are your most popular Italian food options?

Our guests love these customer favorites. If you're visiting us these are some of the food options we recommend most often.

Rigatoni Bolognese — Slow-simmered ground beef ragù tops rigatoni, bringing a meat sauce to this classic pasta dish.
Linguine Vongole — Linguine with clams is sautéed with garlic and olive oil, and diners must choose red or white sauce.
Fioretti Boscaiola — Pasta shaped like small stuffed purses holds four cheeses, then comes with mushrooms, pancetta, cream sauce, and truffle oil.
Truffle Rigatoni — Rigatoni is served in truffle sauce with crumbled sausage and mushrooms, combining pasta with meat and vegetables.
Spicy Rigatoni — Rigatoni tubes are served in spicy vodka sauce, with the sauce providing the dish's defining heat.

Do you offer delivery and takeout?

Yes! We offer both delivery and takeout for italian food throughout the Southeast Annadale, Staten Island area. Order your italian food online for convenient pickup or delivery.