Premium Reserve Pork Chop
$36.00
Pan-seared pork chop with peppers, porcini mushrooms, and broccoli rabe.
“Came down to NYC with my family and had to come to Staten Island and ‘O Sfizio for the pork chops!”
Italian Food to Try
Antipasto Italiano
$37.00
Cured meats, cheeses, olives, fig jam, and crostini make this platter.
Mozzarella In Carrozza
$18.00
Fried mozzarella layered with bread and served with tomato sauce.
Fried Zucchini
$15.00
Breaded zucchini strips are fried and served with tomato sauce.
“This place is absolutely the best Italian restaurant I have been. The food is outstanding without fail. Me and the wife had the arrabiata and it was to die for. The ribeye steak was sooo good too. The service is amazing and very friendly. Worth every penny.”
Melanzane Rollatini
$19.00
Eggplant stuffed with ricotta, tomato sauce, and fresh mozzarella.
“First time here. Food was great and Jerry ( Staff )was professional. If you’re in the area stop in for some great Italian cuisine.”
Pollo Any Style
$29.00
Chicken in a required Italian style with seasonal vegetables and potatoes.
“This is probably the best Italian restaurant that I ever had the pleasure of going to. I had the linguini Capri squid, mussels, and clams. They even gave the option of adding a little spice to it. Plus pork chops are great as well. I highly recommend this plus service is also fantastic.”
Pollo Prosecco
$29.00
Chicken breast in Prosecco cream sauce with artichokes and tomatoes.
“We tried this restaurant today for the first time and we were not disappointed. We told the staff that our daughter just performed in her first show, and at the end of the meal, they brought her dessert out with a flaming candle and sang “For She’s a Jolly Good Fellow. It was absolutely adorable. The food was incredible and the service was even better (Gennaro was a pleasure!) It’s hard to find an Italian restaurant on Staten Island that stands out from the rest, but this place is truly top-notch. We can’t wait to return!”
Pollo Sophia Loren
$33.00
Pan-seared chicken with prosciutto, olives, Sherry sauce, and potatoes.
“Nice, cozy Italian restaurant with excellent food and a friendly staff. Looking forward to going back to try other options on the menu. Spaghetti Carbonara was good. Not overly crowded on a Thursday night, but not dead either. Can't say what a wait time could be like on a weekend.”
Polpette Della Nonna
$19.00
Neapolitan meatballs of pork, veal, and beef in tomato sauce with ricotta.
“We had a wonderful experience at this Italian restaurant! The staff was incredibly friendly, the food was absolutely delicious, and they went out of their way to make us feel welcome. They even helped keep our 1-year-old entertained so we could enjoy our meal—such a thoughtful touch. Highly recommend!”
Pork Chop Scarpariello
$38.00
Pan-seared pork with sausage, potatoes, peppers, and onions in lemon sauce.
“Love the food, love Gennaro, great spot. Try the pork chop. The apps are great too and the bar pours are generous.”
Prime NY Strip Steak
$48.00
Prime NY Strip Steak with roasted garlic, mashed potatoes, and onion rings.
“This is an excellent Italian restaurant — truly one of the best in New York. The food and service are absolutely top-tier, everything was perfect from start to finish. The atmosphere is magical, very cozy, elegant, and welcoming. You can really feel the attention to detail in everything they do. Every dish was delicious and beautifully presented, and the staff made the whole experience even more special. It’s definitely a place you want to come back to again. Highly recommend!”
Ricotta Board
$18.00
Ricotta served with honey and bread for dipping.
“I've been living in New York for 3 years. And for the first time I visited A REALLY ITALIAN RESTAURANT. It's a great place, with delicious food and good wine!!! I recommend everyone to visit this place!”
Risotto Alla Funghi
$28.00
Mushroom risotto finished with a touch of truffle oil.
“Such a great spot! The food tastes homemade — the pasta was fresh, the pizza had the perfect thin crust, and everything was super flavorful. The staff was so welcoming and made us feel right at home. Good portions, fair prices, and just an all-around cozy vibe. Can’t wait to go back!”
Vitello Any Style
$35.00
Veal in a required Francese, Masala, Parmigiana, or Piccata style.
“'O Sfizio never disappoints. We had the Veal chop Parmigiana and Veal Piccata and both were spectacular .”
Vitello Saltimbocca
$39.00
Veal topped with prosciutto and mozzarella in Marsala sauce.
“The best Italian restaurant on the Island. My family and I truly enjoyed our dinner. Absolutely delicious!!!!! Food is so authentic and cooked to perfection. Service was also above and beyond. Mario showed such great hospitality and is absolutely hilarious. We'll definitely be back!!!!! Highly recommend!!!!”
Arancini
$18.00
Rice fritters with Parmesan, mozzarella, and tomato sauce.
Lamb Chops Barolo
$49.00
Lamb chops with pistachios, fig sauce, potatoes, and vegetables.
Pollo Capricciosa
$28.00
Pan-fried chicken with arugula, tomatoes, mozzarella, and balsamic glaze.
